"[Carl Crawford] is not bringing value to the team." That's crazy. You are saying value is all about personality and caring about the team. Putting a lightening fast, .300 hitter at the top of a sick lineup for sure makes a World Series contender.
You and your numbers. You are still associating value with numbers. Let's say we put Crawford on the Angels, his likely destination. Are they now a world series contender because Crawford is there? If you say yes, you will lose all credibility because it's not true.
I'm not arguing that Crawford is not talented, but he's a speed demon playing LEFT FIELD. He should have been a Center Fielder years ago but he "wasn't comfortable" and asked to play left. That's not valuable to anyone. What you are doing is taking away a left field position where you can put a weaker fielder who is a phenomenal hitter (think Ryan Braun or Jose Baustista based on last year). Whatever team Crawford is on, you can't have that because you have to have Crawford there. This brings his value WAYYYY down.
However, if you have a Jayson Werth on your team, he can play anywhere in the outfield. Thus, you can have your Bautista, Braun, or whoever else can't play anywhere in the field, and still have an outstanding outfielder in one of the other two positions. Plus, if you want to get into stats, with Werth you get a little lower average with more power and a higher on base percentage. Don't believe me numbers man. Crawford has a lifetime .337 OBP (which is very poor for a top of the order guy), while Werth has a career .367 OBP. That's a pretty substantial difference and it gets even more laughable if you only take the last 3 years since Werth has come into his own.
Crawford will give you good numbers, and if you are into that because you are a fantasy guy, that's fine. I'm taking the guy who busts his ass and has shown significant growth as a player over his years. If the game is on the line, I'm taking Werth 100 times out of 100 over Crawford.
Well Crawford isn't being put up there with the game on the line. He is up there to start a rally and get guys on baseball (smallball) to score runs.
Buddy, he is going to a contender. Thus, he will be up plenty of times with the game on the line. He's not even a leadoff hitter so you can't make the claim that he's always playing smallball. Even if he was a leadoff hitter, you only lead off a game once guaranteed. The other times, you might be up with the bases loaded, there might be 2 runners on, etc. You have to be able to hit in all situations, ESPECIALLY having the ability to drive in a run when the pressure is on. You have to be able to do it all. I'm telling you, you can have Crawford, but you won't like it come playoff time. There's a reason Tampa Bay is keeping Longoria and letting Crawford walk without so much as even offering him ANY contract.......
I voted!!! My vote remains anonymous, but there is one specific person who knows that my vote was unanimous specifically for him.
You must be logged in leave a comment.
A FanVsFan Challenge is a structured debate between two fans. Each fan gets two turns to prove their case and silence their rival. Other fans can view, vote and comment on the debate. Get involved and vote on the debates below.
See Full Leaderboard
Last Night on the Farm - 8/19/14
First of six games Yankees need goes the wrong way
New York Mets vs Oakland Athletics August 19th, Lineup Cards
Houston Astros vs New York Yankees August 19th, Lineup Cards
The Last Great One. Can Any Athlete Resemble Jeter?
Last Night on the Farm - 8/18/14